Volsky on “Craig Leen Saves City At Least $40,000”
May 24, 2011 Leave a comment
CRAIG LEEN SAVES CITY AT LEAST $40,000
Coral Gables will save over $40,000 by a decision of its new attorney who had recently nullified a parting gift his predecessor bestowed upon her three outside legal consultants on her last day in the city.
City Attorney Craig E. Leen has conformed that hourly legal fee increases, which former city attorney Elizabeth Hernandez unilaterally and retroactively gave her long-time labor consultant lawyer James Crossland and his two associates, were null and void. The increases, he indicated, were economically and professionally unjustified at the time when the city, under the pressure from residents, is making a concerted effort to cut expenses.
Leen said that he personally communicated his determination to Crossland, who apparently accepted it without discussion.
In a broader sense, the invalidation of the Hernandez fee increases appeared to indicate that Leen is actively reviewing the modus operandi of the former city attorney. Hernandez disliked to be sullied by mundane legal functions and, at a large expense to taxpayers, would hire outside attorneys at a drop of a hat for even most elementary chores, among others writing simple letters. By contrast Leen is described as a professional who is willing and eager to undertake most of the city’s legal work himself. This could represent a considerable additional saving for Coral Gables.
Hernandez’ decision to increase Crossland’s hourly fee from $200 to $225, and Denise Keekin’s and David Miller’s reportedly from $180 to $200 each, was spelled out in a letter to Crossland at Bryant Miller Olive law firm, where the three work . Her action caught the city’s commissioners and City Manager Patrick Salerno by surprise. Written apparently in violation of city procedures, it was dated December 30, 2010, Hernandez’ last day as the city attorney.
Several weeks earlier, Hernandez announced she was resigning at the end of 2010. According to well-informed City Hall sources, her departure was far from voluntary. “She saw the writing on the wall,” one official said. “She realized that because three commissioners were privately very critical of her performance, she could have been fired at any moment.” At the time, only Commissioner Ralph Cabrera and former mayor Don Slesnick were known to be in her corner.
(Cabrera continues to be her close friend and, as it were, a custodian of the vestige of her influence in the city. Several City Hall “insiders” said they would be extremely surprised if the two didn’t see each other regularly, exchanging emails frequently, sometimes even texting during commission discussions. Crossland, whom Hernandez hired and who worked with her for years, is a good friend of Slesnick. Earlier this year, apparently for the first time, he and his wife each gave $500 to Slesnick’s re-election campaign.)
In her Dec. 30 letter to Crossland Hernandez wrote: “Please forgive my lateness in responding to your request last month. As we discussed, at the beginning of December, your letter for a fee increase as follows is approved: James Crossland $225 an hour; Denise Heekin and David Miller $200 an hour. Effective December 1, 2010.” The letter was not copied to anyone in Coral Gables, or elsewhere.
Hernandez’ fee raises represented at least 12.5 percent of the amount that the city annually pays Bryant Miller Olive. City records indicate that in the 2009-2010 fiscal year BMO law firm was paid about $400,000. According to city officials, except in cases of an immediate necessity to expend funds, such as during and after hurricanes, any substantial increase in budgetary expenditures, and Hernandez’ action certainly was one, has to be found justified and approved by the city manager, with the acquiescence of the City Commission. Before writing her letter, Hernandez had not sought consent of anybody.
Late in January, after learning about the letter, Vice Mayor William Kerdyk at a commission meeting demanded that the Interim City Attorney Lourdes Alfonsin review the issue and inform him and his colleagues why Hernandez, who by law had to report to the commission, acted behind its back, and whether the fee raise at the time of budget cuts was really necessary. Perhaps out of loyalty to Hernandez, Alfonsin proceeded for months without due diligence and alacrity, leaving the decision up to her new boss who took over as city attorney April 11.
Alfonsin’s inaction, despite Kerdyk’s demand for clarification, in effect put the fee raise in abeyance, and prevented the city from paying Crossland and his two associates, for whom their law firm had already submitted invoices with increased honoraria. Bryant Miller Olive has recently resubmitted the bills with the previous attorney fee rates.Cr