Coral Gables Budget: Public Service Department

Do you know what this Department does?  I was never sure.  It has two big jobs–waste collection and landscape services.  Waste collection includes “residential garbage collection twice weekly and trash collection from the street once a week”.  The landscape services cover “landscape maintenance programs for City properties, including street, sawle areas, selected parks, parkways, and parking lots”.  This also includes forestry management.

Public Service staff have been reduced from 40 to 29 in 2008-2009 and 2009-2010 and from 29 to an estimated 24 in 2009-2010 to 2010-2011.  In two years the number of staff have been reduced 40%  for mainly the lowest paid staff.  Salaries and benefits are being reduced by 28% in two years and services contracted from outside of the Department increased by 24% in the two years.

Hence the total budget of the Public Service Department declined a modest 14% in two years, but much more than the overall city operating budget that declined just 6% over a two year period.

If You Are Not Irritated Now

You will be when you open your 2009 Combined Tax Memorandum Notice and you see what you are paying for a over staffed, over paid, marginally competent city government in Coral Gables, FL.  Don’t forget to add in the fire fee and trash pick costs.  It will be interesting to observe how apathetic voters will be in the coming months.

Coral Gables Citizens Cannot Live by Subsidies Alone

We have taken note of a number of subsidies supplied to residents and nonresidents.

Recently, we are told that the city is trying out subsidies for taxi rides of local residents (supposedly those who might need it by some standard set by the city).

We have learned in recent days that the government had been under-budgeting (doesn’t that mean “hiding) the costs of the famous trolley by about $200,000 annually. (This sounds like another Kerdyk Tax to me.)

The city is subsidizing the construction of a new museum and certainly will have to subsidize its operating costs in the future–it will not be self-financing since there do not exist self-financing museums that I am aware of.

The city subsidizes the cost of trash removal by between 30% to 50% of the costs.

We have the following questions to the city manager and commissioners:

  1. Let the residents see an analysis of the 2008-2009 budget with the end-of-year results laid out in the same categories and details as the budget approved at the start of 2008-2009.  We get an accounting statement at the end of the year with numbers that cannot be compared with the start of the year budget and in comparable categories and items.
  2. We should not be subsidizing people, projects and areas without regard for the known values of the benefit impact and the true beneficiaries of the subsidies. The city cannot afford subsidies now or in the near future.

Poor Economic Prospects for Coral Gables and South Florida: What Can We Do?

I.  In the national and world economic context:

A recent report, “the long climb”, published in the Economist on the economic prospects for the U.S. and the world economy, raises some significant challenges for the financial future and management of the City of Coral Gables.  That excellent report concludes that the economy will necessarily have to take a different path to return to growth because of the nature of the financial crisis that left behind accumulated debt in households, banks and other business that has to be cleaned up over time.  Furthermore, it concludes that consumers will not return to their past spending patterns as they need to reduce their debt overhang through increased savings. This means that neither asset inflation (residence, commercial buildings, the real estate and related businesses) will not be seen for many years.  With consumer spending stagnate only exports will be the basis for long-term growth. (This explains why the U.S. should be pushing China to increase consumer spending and why the U.S. is letting the US dollar weaken.)

Coral Gables needs to look to different kinds of economic sectors and businesses to return to growth in the future.  Failing to do so will mean that Coral Gables will follow a sluggish national and regional economy slow growth patterns for years to come.

II.  In a regional and South Florida context:

In a recent speech of Dennis P. Lockhart, President and Chief Executive Officer, Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta gave an overview of the economy and what is seen ahead for growth and reduced unemployement:

A turnaround in the housing market is key to recovery. The housing market has begun to improve as measured by sales volumes, prices, and new home starts. Yet new and existing house inventories remain high, suggesting a weak residential construction outlook. And house sales are being supported by two government programs.

The consensus among forecasters is something approaching a jobless recovery.

Business spending for capital goods and inventory retrenched dramatically in the recession. Businesses remain very cautious about spending on equipment and software.Banks too have been deleveraging and repairing their balance sheets.

Banks too have been deleveraging and repairing their balance sheets. A return to robust bank lending is unlikely, at least in the near term.

And one of the few bright spots in the economy.

A surprisingly positive factor in the current domestic economy and outlook is the global economy. A worldwide recovery is materializing, led by the developing economies of East Asia and India.

And commercial real estate,

I want to draw attention to a developing risk that could set back the progress being made by banks. That is commercial real estate. The recession weakened the fundamentals of all segments of commercial real estate (retail, office, hotel, warehouse, and—sometimes included—multifamily residential). Vacancies have risen, rents have fallen because of vacancies and renegotiations, and capitalization rates (the discount rate used to calculate value) have risen.

If the growth of Coral Gables cannot depend on high employment, prosperous business, strong demand for real estate and growing property values, then city leaders need to examine what are the new opportunities for this city in the years ahead.  Now is the time to do the planning and preparation of community action plans.